This revised report presents the key developments behind More Than 100 US Legal Experts Warned Iran Strikes Could Be War Crimes — What Later UN Findings Said in a clearer structure, without adding claims beyond the original article.
More than 100 United States-based international-law experts signed an open letter in early April 2026 warning that American military operations in Iran raised serious concerns under the United Nations Charter and international humanitarian law.
The scholars did not issue a court judgment.
They argued that some US strikes and statements by senior officials could amount to violations of international law, including possible war crimes.
Months later, in September, a UN-backed fact-finding mission on Iran said it had “reasonable grounds” to believe two US strikes in February constituted war crimes.
The US government rejected the UN mission’s conclusions.
Who signed the April letter?
The signatories included scholars and former legal officials associated with universities and organisations including Harvard, Yale, Stanford, Columbia and the University of California.
Why their expertise mattered
The group included specialists in international humanitarian law, the law on the use of force, human rights law and military law.
Their collective view carried academic and professional weight but was not legally binding.
What did the letter argue?
The experts raised four broad areas of concern: the legality of resorting to force, the conduct of hostilities, public threats against civilian infrastructure and changes to civilian-protection processes inside the US government.
The UN Charter question
The letter argued that the initial US-Israeli attack on Iran was inconsistent with the UN Charter because there had been no Security Council authorisation and, in the experts’ view, no sufficiently established imminent Iranian armed attack justifying self-defence.
Why that point is contested
US and Israeli officials argued that military action was justified by security threats associated with Iran’s nuclear and missile programmes and regional conduct.
International lawyers disagree over how imminence and anticipatory self-defence apply in such circumstances.
Jus ad bellum and jus in bello
Two separate legal questions are involved.
Jus ad bellum concerns whether a state may lawfully resort to force.
International humanitarian law governs how force is used once hostilities are underway.
Why the distinction matters
Even if a state believes its war is lawful, individual attacks can still violate humanitarian law.
Likewise, an unlawful resort to force does not remove legal protections for soldiers and civilians during the conflict.
The Minab school strike
The open letter highlighted the devastating first-day strike on a girls’ school in Minab.
Contemporary reporting said a very large number of civilians, many of them children, were killed.
What the US said about the school
US officials acknowledged that American forces may have been responsible and said the incident was being reviewed.
Later UN investigators rejected explanations that the school had simply been hit accidentally.
September UN findings
A UN-backed fact-finding mission said there were reasonable grounds to believe the United States committed war crimes in two strikes: one involving the school in Minab and another involving a sports complex and residential area in Lamerd.
What “reasonable grounds” means
It is an investigative evidentiary standard used by UN fact-finding bodies.
It does not equal a criminal conviction or a final judgment by an international court.
The school casualty figures
The UN mission said more than 150 people were killed at the school, including around 120 children.
Earlier reporting used somewhat different totals, illustrating why wartime casualty figures can change as investigations develop.
The Lamerd strike
The mission also examined a strike on a sports facility and residential area in Lamerd that caused civilian casualties.
It concluded that the available evidence raised serious concerns about distinction and verification of targets.
What is distinction?
Parties to a conflict must distinguish military objectives from civilians and civilian objects.
Deliberately attacking civilians is prohibited.
What is proportionality?
Even when attacking a military objective, expected civilian harm cannot be excessive relative to the concrete and direct military advantage anticipated.
What are precautions in attack?
Attackers must take feasible steps to verify targets and reduce civilian harm.
This can include changing timing, weapon choice or cancelling a strike when new information changes the risk.
Threats against infrastructure
The April legal letter also criticised statements by Trump threatening attacks on power and desalination infrastructure.
Why desalination matters
In arid countries, desalination plants can be essential to civilian drinking-water supply.
Damage can therefore create severe humanitarian consequences.
Can infrastructure ever be attacked lawfully?
Yes, if it qualifies as a military objective under the legal test and proportionality and precautions requirements are satisfied.
There is no blanket rule that every power plant or bridge is permanently immune.
Why broad threats are different
International humanitarian law requires target-specific analysis.
Threatening entire classes of civilian infrastructure can therefore raise serious legal concerns.
Hegseth’s rhetoric
The experts criticised statements by Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth dismissive of restrictive rules of engagement.
They argued such rhetoric could undermine respect for humanitarian-law safeguards.
Does rhetoric prove a war crime?
No.
Public statements can be relevant to intent or policy, but a criminal finding requires evidence tied to specific conduct and legal elements.
What the experts asked the US government to do
They urged officials to reaffirm compliance with the UN Charter, international humanitarian law and human rights law.
Why the letter focused mainly on the US
The scholars said their connection to the United States explained their focus.
They also expressed concern about abuses and atrocity risks across the region.
What did the UN mission say about Iran?
The September mission also accused Iranian authorities of crimes against humanity connected with their crackdown on domestic protests.
This is important because the report was not solely critical of Washington.
Why legal rules apply to all sides
International humanitarian and human rights law do not become optional because an adversary commits serious violations.
One side’s unlawful conduct does not legalise unlawful retaliation by another.
The US response to the UN report
US officials rejected the findings and criticised the UN Human Rights Council system as biased.
That response should be included alongside the mission’s conclusions.
Can the UN mission prosecute anyone?
No.
Fact-finding missions document evidence and make legal assessments.
They do not function as criminal courts.
Could the evidence be used later?
Potentially.
Documented evidence may inform national proceedings, international mechanisms or future accountability efforts where jurisdiction exists.
Why the open letter became more significant later
In April, the scholars were warning about possible violations while many facts were still emerging.
The September UN report independently reached serious conclusions about two specific US strikes.
Why that still does not make every US strike unlawful
Legal analysis must examine individual attacks.
A finding about two strikes does not automatically determine the legality of every strike in the campaign.
Why an updated article should distinguish warning from finding
The April letter warned that conduct may amount to war crimes.
The September UN mission said it had reasonable grounds to believe two strikes did.
Neither development is the same as a criminal conviction.
Conclusion
The April letter from more than 100 US-based legal experts was an unusually broad warning from specialists about both the decision to wage war and the way the campaign was being conducted.
Five months later, a UN-backed fact-finding mission said the evidence gave it reasonable grounds to believe two American strikes constituted war crimes.
The US rejected those conclusions, and no international criminal court has issued a final judgment on the episodes described here.
The most accurate way to report the issue is therefore neither to dismiss the concerns nor to present allegations as settled convictions: the experts and UN investigators identified serious legal violations, while accountability and final legal adjudication remain unresolved.
Sources and further reading
See Reuters’ April report on the legal experts’ letter and Reuters’ September report on the UN mission.
Why the phrase “war crime” has a specific meaning
Not every civilian death in war is automatically a war crime. The legal question depends on whether civilians were deliberately targeted, whether the attacker distinguished military objectives properly, whether expected harm was excessive, and whether feasible precautions were taken.
That is why investigators examine targeting intelligence, weapon choice, timing and after-action assessments rather than relying only on casualty numbers.
Command responsibility
International criminal law can in some circumstances hold commanders responsible for crimes committed by subordinates when legal requirements involving knowledge and failure to prevent or punish are met.
That doctrine does not mean senior officials are automatically criminally liable for every unlawful strike.
Why state responsibility and individual criminal responsibility differ
A country can violate international law without every decision-maker committing a prosecutable war crime. State responsibility concerns obligations between states; criminal responsibility focuses on individuals and specific offences.
Why UN fact-finding missions use careful language
Investigators often use standards such as “reasonable grounds to believe” because they are documenting evidence rather than conducting a criminal trial with compulsory witness powers and cross-examination.
What evidence open-source investigators can use
Satellite imagery, geolocated video, weapons fragments, hospital records, witness testimony and military statements can help reconstruct an attack. Each type of evidence has limitations and benefits from corroboration.
Why legal scrutiny continues after fighting moves on
Investigations can take months or years because evidence must be preserved, witnesses interviewed and targeting claims tested. The September findings therefore represented a later stage of scrutiny than the April open letter.